50 Voices of Disbelief – Why We Are Atheists
Edited by Russell Blackford and Udo Schüklenk
Wiley-Blackwell 2009
ISBN: 1405190469
Book Review by Fred Hsu
November 22, 2010
Sometimes mistakes have a way of helping me expand my perspective.
A long time ago, I listened to a short essay by a presumably great magician on NPR’s “This I Believe” program. Unlike other essays read on this program, this one was a belief on the non-existence of something. It was titled “This I believe: I believe there is no God.” The essay brought me to tears, as it beautifully expressed my beliefs in exactly the way I could not.
A month ago I ran across a delightful blog entry titled “Imagine No Religion.” I said to myself, “what a well-written little essay for a blog!” It nicely captured essential arguments against organized religions. Then it stripped away from religious leaders their self-bestowed authority to prescribe moral truths.
No sooner had I looked at the footer of this page than I discovered that it was one of 50 essays from the book “50 Voices of Disbelief,” reposted with permission from the author of the essay, Edgar Dahl, and the publishers. I followed the link on the page to Amazon. Normally I would have stopped there, thinking that I could always get this book later when I had free time. But I spotted the name James (The Amazing) Randi on the list of essayists. I put two and two together, and bought this book, for surely it included Randi’s great essay I’d heard on NPR.
As it turned out, The Amazing Randi did not pen that NPR essay. I later learned that Penn Jillette of the Penn & Teller fame did. But once I started reading the 50 Voices of Disbelief, I found that I could not put it down. I am ashamed to admit that I had harbored an illusion of having read all that there was to write about atheism… that is, until I read, back to back, fifty wildly different essays by fifty freethinkers on this one topic in one single book. Suffice to say that I believe every skeptic out there will find at least some essays here written in the style they love, on some atheistic topics that interest them, argued in some ways they have not read before.
Continue reading →